Japanese Patent Case Summary: 2025 (Gyo-Ke) No. 10077 – Intellectual Property High Court (July 29, 2026)
“Battery”
Overview:
This pertains to a case in which the court rejected the defendant’s (patentee’s) allegation that the lawsuit seeking rescission of a Japanese Patent Office (JPO) trial decision lodged by the plaintiff (the party demanding the patent invalidation trial) lacked legal interest.
▶Summary of Judgement and Link to Full Text (Japanese)
Main Issue:
Whether legal interest is recognized in an action seeking rescission of a JPO trial decision that dismissed a request for patent invalidation, under circumstances where the patent right has expired, and a judgment partially upholding the defendant’s (patentee’s) claim for damages against the plaintiff (the party demanding the patent invalidation trial) has become final and binding in a separate lawsuit.
Summary:
(1) “Even after the expiration of a patent right, as long as there remains any possibility whatsoever that patent infringement could be called into question, a person who faces the risk of such an issue being raised clearly has an interest in invalidating the patent, and has the legal interest in demanding a trial for patent invalidation (and therefore, the legal interest in bringing an action for rescission of a trial decision dismissing a request for patent invalidation). Consequently, in order to find that the legal interest in bringing an action has ceased to exist, it is necessary to recognize, from an objective standpoint, that the possibility of patent infringement being called into question against the plaintiff has completely disappeared, and it should be interpreted that there must exist special circumstances where it is recognized that the patent right has expired and the possibility of claims for damages or restitution of unjust enrichment being made against the plaintiff, or criminal penalties being imposed on the plaintiff, for acts committed during the duration of the patent right has completely disappeared…
(2) Looking at the present case, the subject patent right has already expired…, and a judgment partially upholding the defendant’s claims has become final and binding in a separate lawsuit…; however, the plaintiff’s products that were subject to the separate lawsuit were 13 items of battery energy storage systems and one item of a battery pack specified by product name, and the possibility cannot be ruled out that the plaintiff had manufactured and sold other products during the duration of the patent right that could be subject to enforcement of the subject patent right. As such, it cannot be said that special circumstances exist where it is recognized that the possibility of claims for damages or restitution of unjust enrichment being made, or criminal penalties being imposed, against the plaintiff has completely disappeared, and therefore it is recognized that there is legal interest in bringing the present action.”
Comments:
The defendant (patentee) argued that legal interest should not be recognized on the grounds that the subject patent right had expired, a judgment partially upholding the defendant’s (patentee’s) claim for damages against the plaintiff (the party demanding the patent invalidation trial) had become final and binding in a separate lawsuit, and even if the subject trial decision were rescinded, the plaintiff (the party demanding the patent invalidation trial) would not be able to file an action for retrial (Patent Act Article 104quater); however, the court did not accept this argument.
The court’s finding regarding legal interest is consistent with the collegiate judgment rendered by the Intellectual Property High Court on April 13, 2018 (2016 (Gyo-Ke) Nos. 10182 and 10184) and contains nothing novel; however, it clarifies that the fact itself that invalidating a patent after a judgment upholding a patentee’s claim for damages against an opposing party becomes final and binding does not affect the final and binding judgment does not constitute “special circumstances” for finding that the opposing party’s legal interest in demanding a trial for patent invalidation (and therefore, the legal interest in bringing an action for rescission of a trial decision dismissing such a request) has ceased to exist.
Norifumi KOBAYASHI